1. Is the Lottery a collective act of murder? Explain your answer
Yes, The Lottery is a collective act of murder because the whole town killed Tessie at once, all together. If it wasn't a collective act of murder only one person would kill her when she was chosen to die.
2. Is it morally justified? Explain your answer
I don't think it is morally justified. They shouldn't kill people based on picking paper out of a box and who ever got the one with the dot on it dies. They shouldn't even be killing people. I think it is very unfair for the families that have to go through this and for the person that gets chosen.
3. Is tradition sufficient justification for such actions? Explain your answer
This tradition is not a sufficient justification for this action. This is because there is no "good" reason to kill anyone. They should not pick someone each year to die because it is tradition. Traditions should change.
4. How would you respond to cultures that are different from ours that perform 'strange' rituals? Can you think of any examples?
Different cultures have different traditions and I support that because it is what they believe in and it is normal to them. However it is a tradition like the 'Stoning' where people pick a paper and if it has a dot on it they are chosen to die, in my opinion that is a bad tradition and a bad ritual in their culture. If it is a ritual like The First Nations have where they have their fire ceremonies and tell stories of the wild and the land we leave on, that is a tradition that is good and it has been going on for a very long time because it is a good tradition and nobody has a problem with it.
5. What is Shirley Jackson trying to tell us about ourselves?
She is trying to tell us that things can change and they can be good change. Not all traditions need to stay the same. She also wants us to see that this town is willing to kill one of their friends because the mayor of leader says so, or because they have done it for so many years before this.
6. How does this story connect to the Hunger Games?
This story connects to The Hunger Games because just like there is The Reaping, there is also The Stoning in The Lottery. One person is chosen to get stoned to death if they picked the piece of paper with the dot on it. Two people are chosen to go to The Hunger Games if their names get picked, and they have to fight to the death.
Yes, The Lottery is a collective act of murder because the whole town killed Tessie at once, all together. If it wasn't a collective act of murder only one person would kill her when she was chosen to die.
2. Is it morally justified? Explain your answer
I don't think it is morally justified. They shouldn't kill people based on picking paper out of a box and who ever got the one with the dot on it dies. They shouldn't even be killing people. I think it is very unfair for the families that have to go through this and for the person that gets chosen.
3. Is tradition sufficient justification for such actions? Explain your answer
This tradition is not a sufficient justification for this action. This is because there is no "good" reason to kill anyone. They should not pick someone each year to die because it is tradition. Traditions should change.
4. How would you respond to cultures that are different from ours that perform 'strange' rituals? Can you think of any examples?
Different cultures have different traditions and I support that because it is what they believe in and it is normal to them. However it is a tradition like the 'Stoning' where people pick a paper and if it has a dot on it they are chosen to die, in my opinion that is a bad tradition and a bad ritual in their culture. If it is a ritual like The First Nations have where they have their fire ceremonies and tell stories of the wild and the land we leave on, that is a tradition that is good and it has been going on for a very long time because it is a good tradition and nobody has a problem with it.
5. What is Shirley Jackson trying to tell us about ourselves?
She is trying to tell us that things can change and they can be good change. Not all traditions need to stay the same. She also wants us to see that this town is willing to kill one of their friends because the mayor of leader says so, or because they have done it for so many years before this.
6. How does this story connect to the Hunger Games?
This story connects to The Hunger Games because just like there is The Reaping, there is also The Stoning in The Lottery. One person is chosen to get stoned to death if they picked the piece of paper with the dot on it. Two people are chosen to go to The Hunger Games if their names get picked, and they have to fight to the death.